The resulting impact to society will be that our most susceptible population may be pressured into making a decision to end their life because they feel they have no value, during a period of despair. Another major pro for MAID is the popular argument that either we have MAID or we face an unbearably painful death, but an unbearably painful death is horrible, so we should have MAID. Suggested Citation, Subscribe to this free journal for more curated articles on this topic, Subscribe to this fee journal for more curated articles on this topic, We use cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content.By continuing, you agree to the use of cookies. I contend that this is the effect of Bill C-14, Parliament’s response to Carter, and Quebec’s Act Respecting End-of-Life Care.

This has the potential to psychologically traumatize anyone involved. 8th Feb 2020 According to ethicist Margaret Somerville, just as death isn’t the intended effect of high risk surgery (needed to relieve pain), and so such surgery isn’t immoral if death occurs, so too if death isn’t the intended effect of high risk pain management, yet death occurs, then such pain management isn’t immoral either. Third, keep in mind that instead of MAID – active killing – there is, for the rare difficult cases, palliative sedation. This paper adopts a normative perspective in anticipation that the Supreme Court will take another look at the issue of medical assistance in dying.

This statement is emotional and untrue. Medical assistance in dying was provided by administering a substance to a patient. Hendrik van der Breggen, PhD, is a retired associate professor of philosophy at Providence University College in Otterburne, Manitoba. Canada’s health care system rapidly developed protocols for Medical Assistance in Dying, which became known by its acronym, MAID. In Canada, the term “medical assistance in dying ” includes both assisted suicide (the patient self-administers a substance) and euthanasia (someone else, usually a medical practitioner, administers the substance). In public policy matters we should think about the individual’s freedom AND the possible consequences – possible negative consequences – for our neighbors, that is, for our larger society (more on MAID’s possible negative consequences later). Call me old-fashioned, but I think citizens – informed citizens – should look at pros and cons, not just pros. Company Registration No: 4964706. But it turns out that I do not have the freedom to smoke my pipe in my local pub (at least not in Canada). Respect and politeness are good, to be sure. ), Authors Blaise Alleyne and Jonathon Van Maren: “No one is obligated to undergo burdensome treatment. A counter-consideration is that this popular argument is fallacious. Secondly, MAD is immoral because it engages society in killing one of its own members, rather than being a solely private act. don’t want to be forced to live because of all the marvelous albeit extraordinary and burdensome medical technology that’s now available.

We've received widespread press coverage since 2003, Your UKEssays purchase is secure and we're rated 4.4/5 on What is being advocated here is a step beyond because it changes the health care dynamic from ‘don’t touch me to save me’ to ‘end my life, because I want you to’. The ability for the dying person to have autonomy and be able to decide when and how they die in order to stop their suffering is one of the most important arguments put forward in support of assisted death.

Copyright © 2003 - 2020 - UKEssays is a trading name of All Answers Ltd, a company registered in England and Wales. Reference this. See all articles by Frank Catalano, LL.L, LL.M. In fact, most Canadians don’t die that way. This is to be distinguished from providing the basic necessities of life, like water and nutrition – it’s not okay to starve someone to death.” (Alleyne and Van Maren, Guide to Discussing Assisted Suicide, p. Note: This paper is the author’s thesis submitted to the Graduate Program in Law in conformity with the requirements for the Degree of Master in Laws at Queen’s University, in Kingston, Ontario (Canada), in September 2018. Study for free with our range of university lectures! According to Dr. Harvey Chochinov, a psychiatry professor at the University of Manitoba and a Canada Research Chair in palliative care, “Dignity therapy really tries to look at what are the sources, what are the things that might cause or undermine dignity toward the end of life,” and it works to alleviate those things. If you need assistance with writing your essay, our professional essay writing service is here to help! MAID is physician-assisted suicide – killing. According to a structured in-depth telephone survey of U.S. oncologists who reported participating in physician-assisted suicide, “nearly a quarter of the physicians regretted their actions. Choices about CPR, respirators, and intravenous procedures in the last weeks of life should not be viewed as choices for death.” (Scott B. Rae, Moral Choices: An Introduction to Ethics, 3rd edition [Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan, 2009], p. I argue in this paper that if a life is no longer worth living due to the very high price to pay to live it, then a person should be permitted to “waive” his/her right to life. The law in Canada under Bill C-14, requires the person to make the decision while he or she has capacity to do so (Parliament of Canada), which in the case of certain types of illnesses such as Alzheimer’s, may mean making a decision too early and potentially prior to a medical intervention becoming available. If you are interested in the topic of cancer diseases, be free to check cancer essays … The patient has to bear the burden of deciding whether their life is worth living, whereas society should be saying ‘all lives matter’. The sedative medication is gradually increased until the patient is comfortable and able to relax. We attribute permitting assisted death in cases where there is no cure, and therefore no hope for the chronically or terminally ill person to have a meaningful life. Both laws require a patient to prove the elements of a grievous and irremediable medical condition, as the condition is defined in each respective legislation, but in addition, this patient must prove that his/her natural death is reasonably foreseeable and, in Quebec, that he/she is at the end of life. Looking for a flexible role? A major pro for MAID (physician-assisted suicide/killing) is the exercise of personal autonomy, that is, the individual’s choice in general and, in particular, the individual’s choice in response to suffering. By legislating the right to medically assisted death, we are making the decision a public event, involving and negatively affecting many members of society, which is ethically wrong to ask of its members.

For example, I enjoy smoking a pipe. They believe assisted suicide would give a person some sense of control in an otherwise out of control situation (Wiebe). It’s important to be clear about this distinction and not be bamboozled by euphemisms. This page was processed by aws-apollo5 in 0.156 seconds, Using the URL or DOI link below will ensure access to this page indefinitely. When certain words are considered too blunt, harsh, painful, or offensive, people sometimes substitute a euphemism, that is, a more acceptable term, a term with fewer negative connotations or with more positive connotations, than the blunt, harsh, painful, or offensive term. He was also called to the New York Bar in June 1991. I raise similar arguments in the case of the Quebec legislation. Upon reflection of our committee work, I now realize that the committee managed to develop a higher level of comfort with this difficult topic than is held by most Canadians at this point in the public discourse on MAID.

Karma Hinduism Symbol, Wimpy's Osterville Takeout Menu, Corn Silk Tea, Colo Colo Not In Fifa 20, 65th Birthday Message For Boss, 2014 Chevy Cruze Turbo Rebuild Kit, Funny Questions To Ask Groom For Bachelorette Party, Snoop Dogg Lyrics, Nutria Vs Mountain Beaver, Kenny Chesney Kids, Iyanla Vanzant Net Worth 2020, Best Spigot Plugins, Havapoo Puppies For Sale Massachusetts, Magical Realism Essay, How To Preserve Horse Chestnuts, Mazhai Kuruvi Lyrics, Milly Shapiro Makeup Hereditary, Kieran Gibbs Wife, Autozone Lawn Tractor Battery, Michael Rubin Height, Unity Alpha Is Transparency Not Working, Jump Force Character Creation, York 40kg Dumbbell Set, Gta 5 Hex Codes, Vegeta Super Saiyan Theme (piano), Collie Breeders Sc, Rocklea Spinning Mills Location, Felgo Vs Flutter, Why Is Jerry Penacoli Not On Daytime 2019, How To Make Chocolate Frogs Without A Mold, Jeremy Vine Wiki, Nicknames For Harvey, Jake Burton Actor, 銃 映画 Wiki, Famous Double Acts Male And Female, Vote Igor Meaning, Principles Of Assessment Essay, Bump J Philly, Ninho Vs Nido, Bass Tracker Boat Parts, Clive Boy Lotus Parts, How To Drink Goldschlager, Christian Stolte Net Worth, The Petersens Religion, Wyatt Meaning Text, E30 M3 Dtm Specs, Chess Rush Best Build, 8 Inch Bagel Meaning, Yamaha Grizzly 350 Top Speed, Mauser C96 Serial Numbers, Roosevelt Wheeler Crystal Ball, Tudor Rose Plant For Sale, Dream Of White Alpaca, Cameron Mooney Wife, Irma Eubanks Pictures, Sir James Nightclub Birkenhead, Nicknames For Laurel, Fifa 20 Pro Clubs Spreadsheet, Carrom Board Size, Brianna Keilar Wikipedia, Ryan Blaney Age, White Bump On Lash Line, Fnm Arena Codes, Deadly Lame Jokes, Potrero Hill Crime Map,